What if the Yankees had traded Mariano Rivera in a deadline deal?…
It’s tough. I’ve been preaching the Yankees need to sell and I still believe it. Yet, it was very hard to watch Aroldis Chapman and his 105 mph fastball move to Chicago. I know, it was the right thing to do. The Yankees got a player (SS Gleyber Torres) that knocked #1 prospect SS Jorge Mateo off his perch. They also got promising talent with two other minor leaguers, and the bonus included former Yankee Adam Warren, the perfect spot starter/long reliever. He should slot nicely into the 7th inning role departed by Dellin Betances when he was promoted to the 8th inning with the trade.
Credit: Barton Silverman/New York Times
Andrew Miller is my favorite Yankee. Going back, my favorite Yankees have been long-term affairs. I became a Yankees fan in 1974 when P Jim “Catfish” Hunter signed with the Yankees as a free agent. But it didn’t take long for me to jump to C Thurman Munson as my favorite. There was a short stint with P Rich “Goose” Gossage, but then 1B Don Mattingly became my favorite. When Mattingly retired, Mariano Rivera, then an 8th inning set up reliever for closer John Wetteland became my favorite Yankee. So, from 1983 to 2013, there were two players that were my favorite. When Andrew Miller joined the Yankees, he became my favorite due to his unselfish, total team approach. He’s been great at whatever role he’s held with the Yankees and has never complained. He is now the closer again with Chapman joining the Cubbies. Yet, with several days to the trade deadline, Miller could still soon be an ex-Yankee.
Credit: Elsa/Getty Images
There was a report today that the Washington Nationals might be willing to part with pitcher Lucas Giolito for Miller. A subsequent report indicated the Yankees would not take Giolito for Miller. Realistically and considering he is my favorite Yankee, that’s a trade that I would do with no questions asked. I think Giolito has a very promising future. There are no guarantees for anyone unless your name is Mike Trout or Bryce Harper. Pitchers are very fickle. The Los Angeles Dodgers have the best pitcher in baseball with Clayton Kershaw yet he is on the DL and there’s no word when he’ll be returning. The Yankees need a New York Mets-like starting rotation and I feel that Giolito could be a cornerstone. I would hate to lose Miller, and I would be very sad to see him go even if Giolito is the compensation. Yet, I feel the Yankees would be better off long-term with a potential ace in the rotation and Dellin Betances as the closer.
The Yankees have played better of late but realistically this is not a World Series team. The Yankees really need to make decisions now to influence the 2017 roster. That means they need to move guys like Ivan Nova and Carlos Beltran. Get prospects rather than see the players depart at the end of the year. I am prepared to cut bait with Mark Teixeira, Alex Rodriguez and CC Sabathia. I’d try to move C Brian McCann and 3B Chase Headley. I’d also check to see if there was any value for LF Brett Gardner. I wouldn’t trade P Masahiro Tanaka but I’d seriously have to consider moving Michael Pineda and/or Nathan Eovaldi in the right deal.
The influx of additional young talent could allow the Yankees to make a deal for a guy like P Chris Sale or another impact player.
Owner Hal Steinbrenner and President Randy Levine still believe in the 2016 Yankees but they are definitely in the minority. The Yankees, behind GM Brian Cashman, need to be forward-thinking. The next couple of days will be crucial to the future of the franchise.
As painful as it is, please sell…
To sell or not to sell…
Should the Yankees be buyers or sellers? That seems to be the burning question circulating the Yankee fan base. It’s clear that the 2016 Yankees are not going anywhere. Even if they did somehow snag the second Wild Card spot, what would they do with it? Nothing. They do not match up well with the better teams in the AL and if the big hitters on the team can’t hit in July, they sure won’t be hitting in October when the best pitchers are facing them.
The answer is plain and simple. I think the Yankees could get more for Aroldis Chapman than if they take the compensatory pick when he walks at the end of the year. Carlos Beltran has proven to be a much better Yankee than expected but his time in the Bronx is over. Let Nathan Eovaldi figuure out how to control those 100 mph pitches in PIttsburgh. I’d move Brian McCann to someplace like Texas or another team in need of a quality catcher. I’d cut Alex Rodriguez outright, and take the rest of the contract as the cost of doing business.
Granted, Aaron Judge is currently on the minor league DL but the Yankees need to find ways to get the younger talent exposed to the major leagues this year. I’d like to see Jake Cave have the opportunity he had in spring training when he was trying to make the Cincinnati Reds as a Rule 5 draftee. It didn’t work them but I think he has continued to grow and might be the fourth outfielder that Aaron Hicks is not. Tyler Austin is another possibility.
I realize that pitcher Drew Pomeranz is having a great year, and was once a fifth selection overall in the draft, but he is still a journeyman pitcher. For the success he’s enjoyed this year, the San Diego Padres were able to pry the fourth best prospect from the Boston Red Sox in pitcher Anderson Espinoza. Watching the Red Sox beat the Yankees yesterday, their starter was Eduardo Rodriguez. Rodriguez was the product of a trading deadline deal a couple of years ago when Boston was seller (sending current Yankee Andrew Miller to Baltimore). Being sellers paid dividends for the Red Sox.
Retooling this team is not going to work. The Yankees need to make some extreme choices, and then stand behind those moves. There’s help on the way in the lower levels of the minor league system, with a few options currently at the AAA level. But those players need to be supplemented by other high level prospects.
It’s been frustrating to watch the Yankees fight to .500 at the All-Star Break, only to lose the first two games of a three game set with the Red Sox. But this is the 2016 Yankees. It’s not going to get any better.
I personally would can Joe Girardi as manager, but that’s not a move that necessarily needs to be made to improve the team over the long haul. Maybe it is time to make a change at the GM level. Bring an outside perspective into the organization. I would love for the team to find a way to pry Alex Anthopoulos away from the Los Angeles Dodgers.
The best move would be for the Steinbrenner family to sell the team but that’s not going to happen. So, sell the older players with value, and move on. 2016 is lost. Prepare this team for 2017 and beyond. We need to recapture New York from the Mets and give the fans reason for hope…
So long, Aroldis. It’s been fun…
Credit: Kim Klement, USA Today Sports
Glass is half empty…
When the Yankees split the recent series with the Texas Rangers by taking back-to-back walk-off wins, there was talk if those games were the momentum changers that the Yankees needed to propel them upward in the standings. Off to San Diego to play the lowly Padres, and the Yankees have only continued their disappointing and at times frustrating play.
When you can say that Ivan Nova held the opponent to one run with seven strikeouts, it should be a sign of optimism. But in the standings, it was just another loss as the Padres’ Drew Pomeranz threw a superior game. Is Pomeranz really that good or is it just the miserable Yankee bats? Probably somewhere in between.
Every fan has known for several years that the Yankees need another top starter to go with Masahiro Tanaka. There was hope and optimism that Michael Pineda and/or Luis Severino would step up but it hasn’t happened and there was always the potential for this to be the case. Neither is a surefire option. I still think the Yankees should have gone after Max Scherzer a couple of seasons ago, but it wasn’t meant to be.
Credit: Geoff Burke, USA Today Sports
Regardless of what happens in the coming days, I think it is time to move pending free agent Carlos Beltran. Yes, he’s been the best offensive force on the team, but face it, the Yankees aren’t going to win the World Series this year. Beltran will walk at the end of the year as the Yankees have no desire to re-sign the player. They may as well sell at this point to get something of value in return. The day for Aaron Judge’s arrival is drawing closer. Even if Judge isn’t ready, there are guys like Jake Cave who deserve an opportunity. The Yankees should commit to youth for the good of the organization going forward.
Credit: Corey Sipkin, New York Daily News
I would also sell high on CC Sabathia. The guy was untradeable in the not so distant past. Now, the Yankees could actually get something in return even if they have to pay some of the salary. A great Yankee but it’s time to move on. I’d rather begin to develop guys like Chad Green and Luis Cessa as long time parts for the starting rotation.
I’d sign Cuban free agent third baseman Yulieski Gourriel and unload Chase Headley.
Credit: Kevork Djansezian, Getty Images
There’s no doubt I’d walk away from Alex Rodriguez, and take the remaining dollars as a loss on the contract as the cost of doing business. I would also move on from Mark Teixeira despite no readily apparent back up in place. These guys have been huge drains on the team’s offense, and perhaps they’d flourish elsewhere with the change of scenery but I don’t see either player powering the team to its 28th World Championship.
If Brett Gardner got caught in one of the moves to unload one or more of the above players, then so be it.
The Yankees need to develop a stronger base foundation so that they can enhance the team in the off-season through other trades or possible free agent signings. I know that the free agent market doesn’t appear to be very attractive this year, but the Yankees need to do something to remove the “past-their-prime” players.
As for youth, I was hoping for more from Aaron Hicks. I really thought that he might flourish in the Bronx and give the Yankees stronger reason to move Brett Gardner. But he hasn’t hit either. Maybe the Yankees should consider adding former Twins outfielder Torii Hunter as a roving instructor. Hicks blossomed last year under his tutelage. I still think that Hicks can succeed, but it is rapidly becoming apparent it won’t be this year.
It was frustrating in the off-season to watch the Yankees be so inactive in improving the roster. We’re now seeing the uneven play of the team as a result. I think the fans knew that was the more likely outcome than management did. It doesn’t mean the fans are more educated, but clearly this was a roster full of holes that needed everything to go right.
Today, Chad Green is the starting pitcher as the Yankees try to salvage at least one game from the San Diego Padres and avoid a sweep. Hopefully it is the sign of the future, and the first step toward “roster improvement”.
Yankees, just win…
Win some, lose some…
The Yankees continue to lose but win just enough to make you think that IF everything could fall into place, they might have a shot for a wild card berth. This is actually frustrating because the Yankees do not have the horses to succeed in October outside of a legendary back end of the bullpen.
Credit: Brad Penner, USA Today Sports
There have been a few surprises like the improved pitching of CC Sabathia, but the inconsistency of the starting rotation as a whole and the lack of a true superstar in the heart of the order can only mean the Yankees will be picking in the mid-first round again next June in the amateur draft.
I’ve been pleased with the recent play of Didi Gregorius but he’s still just a place card until top prospect Jorge Mateo is ready for the big leagues. In looking at the Yankees infield, it’s hard to imagine anyone other than Starlin Castro still starting at his position three years from now. Mark Teixeira will be a memory from days past, Brian McCann will probably be the team’s primary DH, and Chase Headley will be making his second go-around in San Diego or some other obscure baseball community.
I have mixed feelings about a July sell-off. The Yankees can certainly get value for guys like Aroldis Chapman and/or Andrew Miller but a stellar bullpen is hard to find these days and is a must to succeed in the play-offs. If the Yankees are indeed out of it, I wouldn’t mind seeing Carlos Beltran moved for prospects or almost anyone else on the team except for Dellin Betances, Miller and Chapman. I guess if the Yankees are offered a player like the Cubs’ Kyle Schwarber, then you do have to consider moving even Run BMC but I hope it doesn’t come to that. Since Mariano Rivera retired, Andrew Miller has been my favorite Yankee. Before Rivera was my favorite, it was Don Mattingly. I am used to players with very long tenures in New York. The difference with Miller is that he was not home-grown. He made his name before coming to New York.
If the Yankees decide they can re-sign Chapman, then maybe moving Miller is the right thing. But if Chapman isn’t traded and is allowed to walk at the end of the year, the Yankees need Miller as their closer. I prefer to see Betances stay in a setup role. I hope he doesn’t become the closer by default.
Trading Chapman or Miller is easy, GM Brian Cashman would really make a name for himself (above and beyond his current reputation) if he was able to unload some dead wood. Yes, I am talking about Alex Rodriguez and Mark Teixeira but there’s obviously others.
Life in the AL East…
I am surprised that the Baltimore Orioles are starting to run away with the division. Honestly, I thought it would be a slugfest between the Toronto Blue Jays and the Boston Red Sox. After a strong start, Boston has been very sluggish of late as they’ve fallen off the pace with the O’s. David Price has looked nothing like the ace pitcher he is paid to be. This really shows what a crap shoot free agent signings can be, particularly with pitchers. Maybe Hal Steinbrenner is on to something by not signing any top shelf free agents in the recent past.
Speaking of Boston, I think they’d be wise to fire manager John Farrell and replace him with last year’s interim manager Torey Lovullo. Lovullo did a great job last year getting the most out of his players after he replaced the sidelined Farrell. The 2016 Red Sox seem to be missing something, and it might be having Lovullo as its manager. But then again, if Farrell causes the Red Sox to miss the play-offs, all is good and they should keep him as manager…
With the Yankees right now, it feels like we’re sitting around waiting for Bryce Harper’s free agent year…
Credit: Rob Carr, Getty Images
Half the year is gone…where did it go? Welcome to July and the baseball trading deadline…
Winter is coming…
“It’s frustrating and hard to watch”.
Those are not my words, but the words voiced by Yankees GM Brian Cashman in an interview with The New York Post.
It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to see that this is a very underwhelming Yankees squad. Outside of a phenomenal backend of the bullpen, there’s not much else to be excited about. The Yankees had improved their play during Alex Rodriguez’s recent stint on the DL but since his return, the Yankees have returned to their losing ways.
Credit: Associated Press
Is A-Rod done? It’s very possible that he is not an everyday player at this stage of his career, even if he is strictly a DH. Carlos Beltran improved his hitting when he had control of the DH slot which further supports that it is unwise to play A-Rod exclusively at the batting only position. A lethargic A-Rod bat is a disease with the anemic bats in the lineup. By comparison, David Ortiz is showing that he is still a killer bat in his final year. A-Rod will not have the same happy ending at this rate.
In another illustration of disappointment, Mark Teixeira exited tonight’s game against the Baltimore Orioles in the third inning. The early report is pain in the knee (although I think he’s more of a pain in my @$$). He’s headed for a MRI so it’s too early to tell if this is a short absence or another stint on the DL for the future ex-Yankee. With no true first baseman on the roster to support Teixeira, Rob Refsnyder was forced into action as the replacement. I wonder if this will mean the call up of either Nick Swisher or Chris Parmalee. Sentimentally, I like the thought of Swisher, but realistically, Parmalee might be the better option.
It’s disappointing to watch the team underperform offensively and struggle with the rotation. It almost certainly means the Yankees will be sellers at the trade deadline which means it is very possible that the Yankee careers of Aroldis Chapman and/or Andrew Miller could be coming to an end. This would have been such a great bullpen to pair with a championship caliber starting rotation, but it has not been meant to be…at least not to this point.
This Yankees roster is so restricted by the plethora of bad contracts. It has resulted in a poorly designed lineup and the weaknesses are routinely exposed on a nightly basis.
It will be interesting to see if Manager Joe Girardi and/or GM Cashman can survive this train wreck. I don’t think Girardi is to blame but it may be time for new blood in the GM seat. I know that he has been committed to the youth movement, but so far, there have not been too many success stories from the younger in-house talent. If I was part of the Steinbrenner family, I’d probably be looking to someone like Alex Anthopoulos, assuming the Yankees could pry him from the Los Angeles Dodgers organization.
Credit: Ron Cervenka
I wish I knew what could be done to reverse the fortunes of the 2016 Yankees but I think there are too many problems to overcome. Sure, a nice little winning streak can mask those deficiencies for the short-term but the team just doesn’t have the sustainability for success over the duration of what’s left of the season.
This is a disappointing season, no doubt.
As I write this, my favorite hockey team, the San Jose Sharks, are playing in the NHL’s Stanley Cup Finals. They are down 2 games to none, but the series resumes Saturday in San Jose. I am still optimistic the team can rebound to make this a competitive series. It’s been great to watch the Sharks reach the first finals in franchise history. For the guys who have been longtime Sharks like Patrick Marleau and Joe Thornton, it is especially satisfying. Hopefully, the return home means there are still some Sharks games to be won.
Are we in or are we out?…
It’s not been a fun start to the 2016 season for the Yankees. While they are playing better (currently in the midst of a three game win streak), the hole may simply be too large to overcome. It’s not like the Yankees have a roster filled with Clayton Kershaw and Bryce Harper types. At the moment, the Yankees are in the AL East Cellar, 6 1/2 games behind the Baltimore Orioles, and 4 games back in the Wild Card standings. This is not insurmountable, especially since it is not yet June. But still, the Yankees will need to make decisions over the course of the next 45 days to buy or sell.
If they sell, I have finally wrapped my head around a potential trade of star reliever Andrew Miller. But if they decide to trade Miller, it is my hope the Yankees will do what it takes to lock up Aroldis Chapman on a new deal rather than letting him walk at the end of the year for draft pick compensation. Maybe it’s Chapman that should be dealt. This is tough. I am a big fan of Miller’s but he is older and Chapman has been electrifying in his short tenure with the Yanks.
Miller is probably at his peak for trade value. He just turned 31 years old, but he is at the top of his game. He can make a difference in the 9th inning for a contender that lacks a frontline closer. Maybe package both Brian McCann and Miller together in a deal with the Texas Rangers. Even the Chicago Cubs, as great as they’ve been, would be better with Miller as their closer.
Miller is probably my favorite Yankee right now. For so many years, my favorite player was Mariano Rivera. Prior to that, it was Don Mattingly. So, it would be painful to see Miller go but if it successfully infused new, young talent into organization, I would be in favor of it.
I wish Mark Teixeira the best in his career going forward, but I am ready for his Yankees career to end. I really hope the Yankees do not try to re-sign him to a new deal after the year is over. Unfortunately, given his injury history and very slow start to the year (again), the Yankees can’t really get value in a trade. Not sure how Greg Bird will perform, but it would probably be beneficial for the Yankees to look for a backup first baseman next year that could spell Bird if he struggles upon his return. I don’t really care to see Teixeira in that role.
Another Yankee that needs to go is Chase Headley. Yet, he is another player with limited trade value. Ronald Torreyes, a player that was acquired from the Los Angeles Dodgers, released, signed by the Chicago White Sox, released, and re-signed by the Yankees in this past off-season has been more exciting despite his small stature. I am still hopeful that Rob Refsnyder will get a chance at some point, but he’s been on the major league roster for a few days now and hasn’t played. Those ugly games at the end of spring training where Refsnyder was hit by grounders still reverberate in my memory (and apparently in the minds of the Yankees brain trust).
I am fine with Didi Gregorius for now, but I recognize that he is just keeping the seat warm until top prospect Jorge Mateo is ready.
Chris O’Meara/AP Photo
Starlin Castro has been a good pickup. I am glad that the team no longer has the revolving door at the position like they’ve had since Robinson Cano left.
In the outfield, it’s clear that Carlos Beltran is making his final lap as a Yankee. His seat on the roster will be taken by Aaron Judge next year. Jacoby Ellsbury is a Yankee for the foreseeable future, like it or not. Brett Gardner would be the one guy in the outfield that I’d try to trade, to free up a full-time spot for Aaron Hicks. Like Miller, he is another player that is now on the wrong side of 30.
The Yankees may not have the talent to bring in a frontline player or top prospect, but they could package the right deal to bring in players with good potential. I always think along the lines of a Paul O’Neill. Those kind of deals don’t happen very often but it is possible.
So far, this is a disappointing year. I felt like the Yankees could have done more to strengthen their roster in the off-season but I understand the need to reduce payroll and to hang on to the upper level prospects. The Yankees do need to clear the path for Gary Sanchez while retaining Austin Romine so that’s why I would be in favor of moving Brian McCann by the trading deadline.
These are the days that will define Brian Cashman’s GM story with the Yankees…
The 2nd best team in New York…
Thankfully, the month of April has ended for the Yankees. As winners of only 8 out of 22 games, they are the current cellar tenants of the AL East. Losing the first two games of a three game set with Boston to end the month is a microcosm of the season so far. No offense, marginal pitching, spotty defense, etc.
Credit: Greg M Cooper, USA Today Sports
The starting rotation has seen only one truly outstanding performance with Nathan Eovaldi’s recent missed no-hitter. Masahiro Tanaka has been steady, but the starting staff has otherwise looked awful. I really thought that this would be the year that Michael Pineda put it all together, but so far, he’s done nothing to show me that his Yankees career won’t end like Jesus Montero’s career ended in Seattle (the guy he was traded for). Montero was cut, and is now toiling in the minor leagues with Toronto.
So much promise and excitement with Luis Severino, and he’s looked like nothing more than a AAA or AA pitcher this year. I’d rather have James Kaprielian in the starting rotation, except for the fact that Kaprielian is currently on the DL.
The bats are not hitting. With the aging Alex Rodriguez, now 40 years old, you do have to wonder if this is the year the bottom falls out. It’s a shame that the DH spot is tied up with A-Rod, when the other older bats in the starting lineup really need to take some time there. Chase Headley is like most pitchers batting in the National League…an automatic out. Jacoby Ellsbury may have the same name as the guy who used to play for the Boston Red Sox but he certainly doesn’t play like that guy.
Credit: Getty Images
I know, it’s still early and there is time to right the ship. But if the Yankees continue down this path, they WILL run out of time. Aroldis Chapman is probably wondering if his arrival in a couple of weeks will be too little, too late. If the Yankees are out of the race by July, it makes you wonder if the proposed great bullpen trio of Dellin Betances-Andrew Miller-Chapman will be broken up by trade before it really gets started.
There’s no question that the Yankees right fielder in 2017 will be Aaron Judge (to replace free agent to be Carlos Beltran), but I wonder how long the Yankees can resist the urge to bring him up this year. This is such a crucial year for him in his development, and he is one that is benefiting by the added time in Triple A. The Yankees wouldn’t call him up to back up other guys. There would have to be a clear and defined role. But at some point, if things continue down the current path, the Yankees will need to think about positioning for next year.
I wish I had the confidence that the older guys can turn it around, but I am just not so sure. GM Brian Cashman did a good job infusing youth over the past year but he needs to continue. The Yankees are still the oldest team in the AL East and it shows.
A couple of years ago, the Yankees had a winning team and the Mets were a team on the edge of financial ruin. How quickly things have changed…unfortunately.
Credit: Mike Stobe, Getty Images
Here’s hoping for more exciting times in May…
Don’t forget to bring your parkas!…
The 2016 NFL Draft has concluded. I can’t say that it was a flashy draft for the Minnesota Vikings but I felt they came away with solid young players. I wanted TCU WR Josh Doctson, but the Washington Redskins took him one spot ahead of the Vikings. The Vikings subsequently selected Ole Miss WR Laquon Treadwell, who may very well have been the Vikings top choice anyway. He fits well into the offense, and should click with QB Teddy Bridgewater.
Credit: Chuck Cook, AP
With their second pick, the Vikings took Clemson CB Mackensie Alexander. I didn’t know anything about Alexander, and had wanted the Vikings to take Virginia Tech CB Kendall Fuller. But the more I read and see about Alexander, the more I like him. The Vikings also took his Clemson teammate in the 7th round, S Jayron Kearse (Jevon’s nephew).
There were other good picks, like Missouri LB Kentrell Brothers, and smash mouth TE David Morgan from UT-San Antonio. But the one that has everyone buzzing is the 6th round selection of international WR Moritz Boehringer. Boehringer (from Germany) discovered football about 5 years ago watching YouTube videos of Adrian Peterson, and never played college football. He played in a German league last year, and was a man among boys. He is clearly a project at best, but the guys has the physical tools if he can put it all together.
Credit: Twitter @AroundTheNFL
I was never a big fan of Rick Spielman. I didn’t particularly care for him when he was the GM of the Miami Dolphins, but under his supervision with the Vikings, their drafts have been very solid every year. The days of big swings and misses are long gone. Not everyone is going to make it, but the Vikings have had more success than not in recent years. They are clearly a team on the rise. Mike Zimmer has been the ideal head coach for this team. I liked former head coach Leslie Frazier, but I like the style of defense that Zimmer has created since his arrival.
I was hopeful that the Vikings would select a young RB for developmental purposes, but the right opportunity never presented itself. Future Hall of Famer Adrian Peterson is down to his final years so the team will need to think about his replacement sooner rather than later. Hopefully the additional picks they picked up for next year by trading their third round selection to Miami this year will allow them the chance to nab a productive young back.
I know that his potential is average starter at best, but I liked the Vikings’ free agent signing of Wisconsin QB Joel Stave following the draft. Under Norv Turner’s leadership, I think Stave can be developed properly and will eventually prove to be a good backup for Teddy Bridgewater. Current backup QB Shaun Hill is 36 so a younger, reliable backup will be needed.
All in all, the Vikings are well positioned heading into the 2016 season. I just look forward to the day that I can say that about the Yankees…
I-80 East, please…
The Scranton/Wilkes-Barre shuttle has begun its 2016 season as the Yankees called up lefty reliever Tyler Olson in advance of Friday’s opening series against the Seattle Mariners and former friend Robinson Cano. Headed the other direction was pitcher Luis Cessa.
For Cessa, I think this is a good move. With the season-ending loss of Nick Rumbelow to Tommy John surgery, the Yankees needed another candidate for starting with the Triple A club. Cessa was being used as a reliever, but his highest and best use at this point is as a starter. It’s good to see him get the opportunity to get stretched out. Ivan Nova’s implosion the other night shows there’s opportunity for someone who could grab the long man/spot starter role and run with it. Nova, so far, is not proving to be that guy despite his successful first appearance in long relief.
I don’t know what the Yankees should do with Nova. I’ve lost my patience with him, but he just doesn’t have great trade value. Would a change of scenery help him? I am not so sure. He’s too talented for the Yankees to cut, but too inconsistent to trust.
Tyler Olson gets his first chance as a Yankee against the team that he played for last season. It’s kind of funny that I was disappointed when the Yankees traded former prospect Rob Segedin to the Los Angeles Dodgers for Olson and infielder Ronald Torreyes. All spring, I kept hearing Segedin’s name in the Dodgers lineup, and all in all, he played well. Yet, with the regular season upon us, both Olson and Torreyes are in the majors while Segedin was sent down prior to the start of the season.
Forget the walk-up music in Chicago…
Starlin Castro continues to impress me with his bat and his glove. He doesn’t look like a “newbie” at second base. I know that shortstop is the glamor position but great second baseman are hard to find, and it is such a critical position. I think Castro is the right man for the job in the post-Robinson Cano era.
Credit: Kim Klement / USA Today Sports
I wish I could say that other guys on the team were impressing me. So far, it’s been a sluggish start, offensively-speaking. I am growing concerned that the Yankees have an albatross in Chase Headley, and Alex Rodriguez is a 40 year old man (probably older than many coaches at this point) and finding difficulty finding the ball with his bat. There has been the occasional glimmer of hope from the other position players, but collectively, the group has underperformed. I know, good pitching beats good hitting. But the Yankees do not seem to be taking advantage of the mistake pitches or the #4 or #5 starters on the opposing teams.
I do have to put a disclaimer for Ronald Torreyes. I really wanted Rob Refsnyder to win the utility role but his miscues at third base late in spring training proved that he is not quite ready for the position. In stepped Torreyes and despite his small stature, he has proven to be a very capable performer. Houston’s Jose Altuve has proven that you don’t need to be tall to be successful. Not that Torreyes will ever be the player that Altuve is today, but for what the Yankees need, he has provided.
Credit: The Greedy Pinstripes.com
I liked the enthusiasm that Nick Swisher brought to Scranton/Wilkes-Barre in his return debut in the Yankees organization, but I am still skeptical that his knees will allow him to return to the big leagues. Of course, I hope I am proven wrong, but we’ll find out within the next month or so if he is able to do it. The downside if he does make it is the adverse impact it would have on Dustin Ackley for playing time. I still remain optimistic about Ackley, and I like his bat. That’s probably another reason I am pessimistic about Swisher, but I agree that Swisher knows and understands first base better than Ackley even if the latter did play the position before his professional career started.
Credit: Bill Tarutis / For Times Leader
I miss those perfect games by Davids Cone and Wells…
Another concern is the marginal starting pitching the Yankees have experienced through the first two runs through the rotation. In particular, Michael Pineda and Luis Severino have been the most disappointing. I am really looking forward to seeing a dominant pitching performance from one of the guys. Hopefully that will help turn the momentum and raise the group to their potential. Pineda and Severino are the keys to the rotation so if they can’t turn it around, it’s going to be a long season.
I know that it is still very early in the season and I am certainly not ready to push the panic button. As slowly as the Yankees have started, they can easily get on a hot streak. Weather-wise, the Yankees have really had it tough. They started in New York, went to Detroit and Toronto, and are now back in New York. Meanwhile, the Los Angeles Dodgers play in a climate that is supposed to reach the high 80’s today. Big difference. Granted today is supposed to be sunny and 65 in New York, but that’s not been the case the last couple of weeks. As the weather warms, hopefully the Yankee bats will follow suit.
The Man in Purple…
On a final note, I was glad to see Jared Allen sign a one-day contract to retire as a Minnesota Viking. He wasn’t an original Viking as he came to the team via a trade with the Kansas City Chiefs, and he went on to play for the Chicago Bears and the Carolina Panthers after leaving Minneapolis. Yet, he felt that the Vikings were home. He played his best years in purple, and he will be remembered as one of the great ones. I wish him all the best in his post-playing career and retirement. Thanks for the memories.
The Knight’s Watch…
As we progress into the early stages of the 2016 season, there’s been a consistent theme already. Rare is the starter who gives the team any distance, forcing Manager Joe Girardi to go to the pen earlier than desired. Fortunately, the pen has been as strong as the starters have been weak so it’s balanced out. However, anyone knows that over an extended period, it is a formula for disaster as the bullpen will become overtaxed.
I really thought that we’d see the Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Shuttle running by now but so far Girardi has stuck with his original 25. It is only a matter of time until the rotation begins.
I felt bad for the Yankees and their schedule in early April. After opening at home, they are in Detroit and then head to Toronto. These are not exactly parts of the country that one would vacation in this time of year for the weather. This is when it would have been great to play the Tampa Bay Rays or the Los Angeles Angels on the road. If Aroldis Chapman is missing playing with the major league team, he just needs to look at the weather forecast to see that it is only 33 degrees right now with an expected high of 41 and mixed with snow and rain. I don’t know, I think I’d rather be working out in Tampa.
Credit: Highlight Hollywood
After the first run through the starting rotation, not one of them stood out as a quality performance. The Yankees are lucky they have won more than they have lost at this point (3-2). Their losses have been against two frontline starters (Houston’s Dallas Keuchel and Detroit’s Jordan Zimmerman). So at least they are taking advantage of the opposing teams’ lesser starters. Of the Yankees’ starting five, I was most disappointed in Michael Pineda. He got the win thanks to run support (16), but gave up 6 runs. The Yanks need the pitcher to take charge and deliver quality start after quality start to be successful.
Mark Teixeira, Carlos Beltran and particularly Starlin Castro have played very well. Teixeira is a notoriously slow starter and he stayed true to form in spring training. But early on, he’s already hit a couple of crucial home runs. Beltran, the old man, just keeps hitting. It’s a given that this is his final year in pinstripes as he is just keeping right field warm for Aaron Judge at this point, but he has shown he was a good three year investment. Castro has fit in very well with the Yankees, and has bonded with double play partner, Didi Gregorius. He has shown the best bat at second base since Robinson Cano departed. He may never be Cano, but he has turned second base from a weakness to a strength.
Credit: Thomas A Ferrara, Newsday
The naysayers are down on Jacoby Ellsbury and I’ve already heard the statements that he is the worst free agent signing in team’s history. But I am hopeful that as the weather warms, so does Jacoby and that he is able to stay healthy this year. When healthy, he is still the team’s best player. I think he has the chance to show fans that he can still be the player he was in Boston.
I don’t know. When I saw that Nick Swisher is working out in Tampa at the Yankees facilities and will be signing a minor league deal that includes an opt-out, I had mixed feelings. He was a productive player, who energized the locker room during his prior time in the Bronx. However, age has caught up with him in recent years, and it led to his release from the Atlanta Braves earlier this year.
I suppose that since his only role would be to back up Mark Teixeira at first, it is at least worth taking a look to see if anything is there. I probably prefer to see Chris Parmalee called up at this point if the Yankees want a true first baseman rather than relying on middle infielder/outfielder Dustin Ackley. I thought James Loney might be a better fit, but he signed a minor league deal with the San Diego Padres.
Swisher should be motivated as he’s running out of options to continue his major league career.
Time will tell if he is able to make it back to the Yankees’ major league roster. If he does, I’ll gladly cheer for him as it will have proved he does still have something left in the tank. If he doesn’t make it, I remain grateful for the time he spent with the Yankees earlier in his career.
Credit: Getty Images
* * *
Here’s hoping that warmer weather and better starting pitching is right around the corner…
Can we take a mulligan?…
At long last, the regular season has arrived. There’s always great anticipation for Opening Day, and it was made even more special this year since the Yankees opened at home. The problem was the opponent. Contrary to what you might believe, the Steinbrenner family doesn’t own the Yankees, Dallas Keuchel does. Fresh off last year’s one game Wild Card loss to the Houston Astros and Keuchel, the Yankees very next meaningful game was against the same opponent (team and pitcher). Despite finally scoring a couple of runs, the results were the same. A loss.
It’s a disappointing way to start a new season. I was so envious of the fans of the Los Angeles Dodgers. They opened in San Diego with the most convincing Opening Day victory ever in whitewashing the Padres, 15-0. That’s how to excite a fan base! They followed it up the next day with another shutout.
Masahiro Tanaka pitched well enough to win, but a controversial play in the 8th inning against reliever Dellin Betances cost them the game. At this point, I am indifferent whether the Astros runner should have been called out when he ran inside of the base path, but really, if the game comes down to one play, it’s a game the Yankees probably shouldn’t have won anyway. Of the Aroldis Chapman-less bullpen, you don’t expect the first reliever to fold to be Betances. But it is what it is, and the Yankees still have 161 more games to play to prove they belong in the play-offs.
The Man Cave…
I was hopeful that the Cincinnati Reds would offer Rule 5 pick Jake Cave back to the Yankees, and I got my wish. However, when it happened, I did feel remorse for the player. He had been excited to get an opportunity to go to Cincy and to play in his first big league spring training. The excitement was compounded because there were guys he knew from the Yankees organization (namely the players sent to the Reds for closer Aroldis Chapman…guys like Eric Jagielo and Rookie Davis). He hit well early in camp and then tailed off. But the reports were continuing that he’d stick with the Reds as their fourth outfielder. In the end, it wasn’t meant to be and after clearing waivers, he was offered back to the Yankees. The Yankees accepted and promptly sent Cave down to AA. There was no room in AAA due to a surplus of outfielders.
Time will tell if he gets an opportunity in New York. I hope he does, but if it doesn’t happen, then I hope he finds an organization to give him the chance.
The Opening Day Roster…
There were no great surprises when the roster was announced. Once Gary Sanchez and Rob Refsnyder were sent down, it was a given that Austin Romine and Ronald Torreyes or Pete Kozma would make the team. On the relief side, Bryan Mitchell’s toe injury and subsequent surgery (out four months) opened the way for Kirby Yates to make the team. I was glad to see Luis Cessa make it, and perhaps he can show something to take a larger role going forward. It will be interesting to see how Ivan Nova adjusts to the long man/spot starter role vacated by former Yankee Adam Warren. While I think Nova pitched better than CC Sabathia in spring training, I agree that Sabathia would not be a good fit in the pen. He either needs to succeed as a starting pitcher or the Yankees should just release him and cut their losses. Nova’s time will come. If he perseveres and can eliminate the bouts of inconsistency, he’ll get another chance at the rotation.
There’s no doubt the Scranton/Wilkes-Barre shuttle will be running in full force again this year so the guys on the roster today won’t be exactly the same by the time Chapman returns in May.
GM Brian Cashman is playing a masterful game of chess as he continues to rebuild the Yankees. They may not win the World Series this year, but this is a team that is clearly on the rise. As long as Cashman continues to make the right moves, the future is bright in the Bronx.