All your people must learn before they can reach for the stars…

The Changing of the Guard…

The title of this post is a line by Captain James T. Kirk in the original TV Series Star Trek, but it holds true for the Yankees.

tes290116_12_cosmic2

Who knows if the youth transfusion in the Bronx will be enough to push the Yankees into the play-offs this year.  But at the moment, they are only 2.5 games behind for the last Wild Card slot, but with four team to leap frog.  Regardless of what happens, baseball in the Bronx has become exciting again.  I don’t think the Yankees will pull it out this year, but I am very excited for the future.

The Gary Sanchez Era has begun with the most legendary start in baseball history.  Yesterday, he became the fastest player to reach 11 home runs at the start of a career.  I’ve always remembered how beautiful it was to watch Darryl Strawberry hit home runs, and Sanchez has one of those swings that I love to watch the follow through.  He may be young, but he is a professional hitter with the potential for long term sustained success in pinstripes.  Before he is done, his name will be mentioned among the greats in Yankees history.  Just like center field has long been a position of legends (current starter excluded), the Yankees have a deep history with legendary catchers.  Bill Dickey, Yogi Berra, Elston Howard, Thurman Munson, and Jorge Posada represent rich tradition.  If Sanchez stays healthy, he’ll join those names one day.

gary_sanchez_v_orioles

Credit:  Ray Stubblebine, The New York Post

It is amazing that Sanchez is only 23.  It seems like he has been a Yankees prospect for so many years, having signed at age 16.

Brian McCann is still a very good major league catcher, but he lost the position through no fault of his own.  I hope the Yankees to the right thing and trade McCann to a team that can use his skills, even if it involves paying part of the contract.  I personally would like to see him have the opportunity to return to Atlanta since he is a Georgia native.  Even without McCann, the battle for the backup catching position will still be competitive next spring with Austin Romine and AAA catcher Kyle Higaskioka (assuming the latter is tendered a contract in the off-season).

kh

Credit:  BeGreengo, Flickr

The other young players, such as 1B Tyler Austin and RF Aaron Judge, have under-performed since their dramatic back to back homers in their first major league at-bats.  But I know that Judge will figure it out.  He struggled in AAA last year before dominating this year.  Austin will most certainly yield 1B to the returning Greg Bird next spring, but I also think that he’ll figure it out.  He would slot nicely on the team as the backup first baseman, but someone who could also see time in a corner outfield role and DH.  While their bats have been quiet in recent days, their youthful presence on the formerly aged Yankees roster has been huge.  They have helped restore excitement in the Bronx.

I can’t say enough about how well Luis Cessa and Chad Green have been for the starting rotation.  Like everyone else, I was dismayed when lefty reliever Justin Wilson was shipped to the Detroit Tigers last off-season for two minor league prospects.  While neither Cessa nor Green carry the potential for elite stuff, they’ve been exactly what the team needed after losing Nathan Eovaldi and trading away Ivan Nova.  Andy Pettitte proved long ago that you don’t need elite stuff to be a very successful major league pitcher.  I am not saying that either Cessa or Green will ever be the pitcher that Pettitte was, but it’s good to see young pitchers succeed.  I can still remember when Al Leiter first came up and had some early success.  But he also struggled, and the team had no patience under the George Steinbrenner regime so Leiter was traded away.  He went on to have a very successful major league career.  Under Hal Steinbrenner, Cessa and Green will be given every opportunity…and the time…to prove they belong to stay.

Training camp next spring should bring a renewed enthusiasm for young players.  Now is not the time to be an aging veteran on the Yankees’ roster.   It would be great if the Yankees could figure out a way to unload veterans like Jacoby Ellsbury and Chase Headley, but sadly, they’ll probably be stuck with those contracts to the end.  I am already looking forward to the day that Clint Frazier takes over center field.  3B prospect Miguel Andujar looks like the eventual successor to third, barring any trades, but he’s still a few years away.

I have full confidence that GM Brian Cashman will continue to make the right moves to restore the winning tradition in Yankee Stadium.  Excitement and optimism can be contagious, and Cashman has started something special for the future.

It’s a good time to be a Yankees fan!

—Scott

So far, so good!…

The right decision…

I feel vindicated in my belief all season that the Yankees needed to jettison some of the larger contracts and go young.  There has not been one point this season that I’ve felt the 2016 Yankees are capable of going to the World Series.  They have been, and remain, within distance of the last Wild Card berth, but seriously, this team is about as capable of winning a play-off game as last year’s team.

07LIVEBLOGgirardi-facebookJumbo

Credit:  Richard Perry, The New York Times

But things are changing.  The excitement and energy of the media-labeled “Baby Bombers” has been tremendous.  The August games have become the best games of the season.

Yankees fans have known about Gary Sanchez for years.  He surfaced on the radar as a teenager, and was at times the top prospect in the organization.  But his road did contain a few bumps along the way, and he exhibited signs of immaturity in his earlier minor league days.  He was also labeled as purely an offensive catcher.  Still, he has been nothing short of magnificent since his arrival on the main stage.

With 6 home runs and 12 RBI’s since relocating Brian McCann to DH, Sanchez has clearly proven he is the future.  It is hard to tell what his career will hold, but he brings promise that rings the names of Bill Dickey, Yogi Berra, Elston Howard, Thurman Munson and Jorge Posada among others.  He has guaranteed that McCann’s days as a Yankee will soon come to an end, even though it will take Cash* and cash to move him.  The bat has been as advertised, but it’s the defense that has truly impressed me.  Sanchez has shown that he can handle veteran pitchers, and he is already the owner of the most dynamic defensive plays of the year for the Yankees at catcher.  (*GM Brian Cashman)

denboweb17s-1-web

Credit:  Corey Sipkin, The New York Daily News 

OF Aaron Judge and 1B Tyler Austin burst onto the scene with back-to-back home runs in their first major league at-bat’s.  Judge has continued to hit even if Austin has not.  Yet, they’ve shown that their better days are yet to come.  Austin will most certainly yield first base to Greg Bird, when he returns from injury next spring.  Judge has grabbed a hold of right field and will not be letting go anytime soon.

Brett Gardner can continue making great plays in the outfield but even his time may be coming to an end.  While OF Clint Frazier will not be making an appearance this year (per Yankees’ management), he’ll be in Tampa next spring proving that he is nearly ready (if he’s not already there).  He’ll either take left field or slide Jacoby Ellsbury to left if he shows that he can play center field in the majors.

Too bad the Yankees don’t have a great third base prospect ready and waiting…

On the pitching side, the two off-season acquisitions from the Detroit Tigers have been great (Chad Green and Luis Cessa).  Cessa was the more heralded of the two prospects but Green has been the most impressive so far.  At the time of the trade, the Yankees were heavily criticized for moving an effective left-handed reliever (Justin Wilson) but in retrospect, the trade had to be made.  This was great foresight by Brian Cashman.  Without Green and Cessa, the pitching rotation would be in shambles with the loss of Nathan Eovaldi and the ineffectiveness of CC Sabathia as the season has progressed.  Even worse, if Green and Cessa weren’t Yankees, Ivan Nova probably still would be.  Time will tell if Green and/or Cessa are in the starting rotation, but right now, they are a significant part of the youth movement.

chad green

Credit:  Jim McIsaac

592611322

Credit:  Stephen Dunn, Getty Images

I am looking forward to the future major league arrivals of James Kaprielian, Dietrich Enns, Jordan Montgomery, Ian Clarkin, and Justus Sheffield as we will surely see some of those names next spring.

There is sadness with the departure of long-time Yankees, but for a team that looked so old just a couple of years ago, the future is young and bright.  The Boston Red Sox will be a force for years to come, thanks to their farm system.  At one point, there was a huge gap in the future outlook for both teams, but I think the Yankees have gone a long way toward bridging that gap.  I wish 2B Yoan Moncada was on our side instead of theirs, but the Yankees will continue to make the right moves to level the playing field.

Scranton/Wilkes Barre will continue to be a gold mine for the future of the Yankees.  Life is good…

Nothing against Tommy John, but I didn’t really want to hear his name again…

The Yankees were dealt a blow when it was announced that Nathan Eovaldi had to undergo two surgeries, including Tommy John surgery.  He had shown glimpses this year of the pitcher that he could be.  Now, assuming he stays in the Yankees organization, he will not re-appear until sometime during the 2018 season.

It had been long assumed that Masahiro Tanaka would be the next pitcher lost to TJ surgery so it was surprising that Eovaldi beat him to it.

I wish Eovaldi the best during his recovery and rehabilitation, and I do hope the Yankees find a way to bring him back given that he’ll most likely be non-tendered in the off-season.

With the loss of Eovaldi, I look for Brian Cashman to swing an off-season deal for a young pitcher with potential.  Of course, it also opens the door for more opportunity for the farm system.

—Scott

On a clear day, I can see forever…

The future is bright…

o-SUCCESS-BOOK-facebook

 

This was a difficult week.  For months if not years, I have wanted Alex Rodriguez to go away.  He may have said and did the right thing after the year-long suspension, but there have been too many indiscretions and lies for me to be willing to move forward with the player.  Yet, for his final game, I was sad.  I was and am ready for the Yankees to turn the page, but for one night, it was good to see A-Rod smash the RBI double and to watch him play third base for one out before walking off the field to the ovation of the fans.

I do not argue that he is among the all-time greats.  But I will always wonder what could have been if not for the lies and PEDs.  I think he would have still been among the greats without illegal performance enhancement.  But we’ll never know.  I don’t think we’ve seen the last of A-Rod on the playing field, but obviously, his career in pinstripes is over.

alex-rodriguez--0aa1b3c2e50c926d

Credit:  John Munson, NJ Advance Media for NJ.com 

With A-Rod’s departure, I was very excited to see the arrival of slugging first baseman Tyler Austin and outfielder Aaron Judge.  As Mark Teixeira plays his final games, it is time to look to the future.  I prefer filling the first base vacancy in-house versus trade or free agency.  It was tough to lose top candidate Greg Bird for the season, but Tyler Austin has emerged as a force to be reckoned with.  It should be a great competition next spring between Bird and Austin.  Bird probably still has the leg up but it remains to be seen how he responds as he returns from injury.

The Yankees have been fortunate to have a string of successful first basemen.  From Don Mattingly to Tino Martinez to Jason Giambi to Teixeira, the Yankees have been spoiled even if there have been some down years by the latter two.  But of these great players, only Mattingly was raised through the Yankees farm system.  I remember in the early 80’s when Steve Balboni was the heralded first base prospect, but you kept hearing about this young kid from Evansville, Indiana that could hit.  Greg Bird has received similar accolades for his hitting ability.  I don’t know if Bird can ever be the player that Mattingly was but I am excited that the fight for first base is among two top Yankees prospects.

hi-res-6efcb781a941df75339888dbd78846d1_crop_north

Credit:  Jim McIsaac/Getty Images

Saturday, August 13th will be remembered as the day Tyler Austin and Aaron Judge arrived at Yankee Stadium.  They became the first teammates to homer in their first major league at-bat’s when they hit back to back homers in a win over the Tampa Bay Rays.  The homers were a signal that the future is bright.

mccarronweb14s-1-web

Credit:  John Munson, AP

Gary Sanchez has already positioned himself as the future at catcher.  He continues a long lineage of great catchers (Bill Dickey, Yogi Berra, Elston Howard, Thurman Munson, and Jorge Posada to name a few).  He has yet to prove that he belongs in their company, but he does have the talent and potential to be.  Sanchez’s arrival will almost certainly lead to the departure of Brian McCann.  Even if they have to include cash, I still expect the Yankees to move McCann…either by the end of this month or in the off-season.  Austin Romine has proven that he is a very capable backup catcher for the foreseeable future.

Aaron Judge might not be the Yankees’ top prospect, but his arrival is very exciting.  There has been a vacancy in right field since Carlos Beltran was traded to the Texas Rangers.  There was no doubt that right field would belong to Judge in 2017, even if he did struggle somewhat in AAA last year.  But this year for the Scranton/Wilkes Barre RailRiders, Judge has been a man among boys.  He gives the Yankees a legitimate power threat in right, and his mammoth home runs will ensure that he is a fan favorite.  For a team that has been void of true superstars, the Yankees are starting to show the glimmer of possibilities as we move forward.

GM Brian Cashman has already said that we won’t see top prospect OF Clint Frazier, but he’ll make his first appearance in spring training.  He clearly has the potential (and fire) to make Brett Gardner an ex-Yankee.  Sadly, Jacoby Ellsbury is not going anywhere thanks to his excessive contract, but still, an outfield of Judge, Frazier, and Ellsbury is very exciting.

SS Gleyber Torres and SS/2B Jorge Mateo are a couple more faces that we’ll see next spring.

-69103ba13f8ddfe8

Credit:  Tim Holle, Brevard County Manatees (via NJ.com)

If only Luis Severino, currently 1-7 (with the only win coming in a relief appearance), could deliver upon the promise that he showed last September.  But soon, names like James Kaprelian, Justus Sheffield and Ian Clarkin will be making noise for big league roles.

For a team that was old with a barren farm system just a few years, the future is indeed bright.

I am very excited and anxious to see what the new generation of Yankees can do.  The path to World Championship #28 seems much clearer these days…

—Scott

The Right Decision…

And then there was 24…

It could be the name of a highly successful TV series starring Kiefer Sutherland, it could be former Yankees great Constantino Martinez, or it could be new and future catcher Gary Sanchez.  But today, the meaning is singular.  The Yankees’ roster has essentially been running at 24 for the last few weeks with Alex Rodriguez sitting idle on the bench.  But now, it’s official.

arodsilo1

Credit:  Newsday

The roster action will be delayed but Friday, August 12th represents the final day with A-Rod in pinstripes.  After the game on Friday, Alex will be unconditionally released and will sign an agreement with the Yankees to serve as a special advisor and instructor through December 31, 2017.

Obviously, the roster will stand at 24 only momentarily as the 25th spot will quickly be filled by someone like Aaron Judge or Tyler Austin.  I suspect that it will be the latter as the Yankees will want to test one of the prime candidates to be Mark Teixeira’s replacement next year.  Aaron Judge’s ascent to right field in the Bronx is a clearer path than the one Austin faces given the competition presented by Greg Bird and Rob Refsnyder.

I have not been a supporter of A-Rod and have actively wanted him off the roster for a few years now.  I do recognize that when he came back after serving the year long suspension, he was a model citizen.  He did not exhibit the narcissist behavior that had been such a part of his persona and infamy.  Still, I have been ready to turn the page.

With the ascent of Gary Sanchez to the major leagues and the first few games showing that he is ready, it signaled the turning of the page.  The sell-off at the trading deadline showed that Team Hal was ready to move forward and look to the future.  Sanchez proving that he is ready to be the next great Yankees catcher, it has accelerated the plans to make Brian McCann either a first baseman or the full-time DH.  The transition to the latter would make more sense.  Of course, that would eliminate any chance of A-Rod getting any further at-bats.  I still hold up hope the Yankees will pay some cash to move McCann back to the Atlanta Braves. But it’s actually good that the DH slot has been opened up as it will allow guys like Jacoby Ellsbury and Brett Gardner to cycle through the slot.

Back to A-Rod, I do think that he should pursue a role in the broadcasting booth in the fall play-offs.  He showed that he had great value last year, and I do think he has a bright future in his post-playing career.  The way he enjoys working with young players also shows that coaching is a strong possibility even if A-Rod says otherwise.  Regardless, A-Rod has no shortage of future possibilities.  I am thankful for his contributions to the New York Yankees, but I am glad this day has arrived.  I will look forward to the August 12th game and will watch it with great interest.  I will enjoy each A-Rod at-bat, and I will appreciate his final farewell.

alg-a-rod-2-jpg

Credit:  Corey Sipkin, New York Daily News

So long, A-Rod…

—Scott

Sold to the Lady in the Second Row…

Going, going, gone!…

My wish was answered.  I had been a huge proponent of being a seller at the trading deadline, and in the end, Team Hal saw the view of the world the same as I.  Without any doubt, it was an incredibly painful experience.  I loved having the three-headed beast in the back end of the bullpen, and Andrew Miller was easily my favorite Yankee.  But as I played over and over in my head, having the greatest bullpen in the history of baseball means nothing if you don’t have a supporting cast.

Bullpen

Credit:  Thomas A. Ferrara, Newsday

I thought that GM Brian Cashman did very well with his trades.  It instantly catapulted the Yankees to the upper echelon of premier farm systems when it wasn’t that long ago we were closer to the bottom.  The end of the latest Yankees dynasty came because the team didn’t pay proper attention to the farm system until it was too late.  Now, as the cream of the crop make their way to Yankee Stadium, the team will be in a much better position to add additional pieces to improve the talent and quality of the major league roster.  The bullpen may be more suspect, but the supporting cast will be much, much stronger, and in the end, it will bring more wins.

The future started this week with the call-up of top catching prospect Gary Sanchez.  It’s only been a few games but it feels like the changing of the guard.  I have to believe that it is virtual certainty the Yankees will try to move Brian McCann at the end of the season if not sooner.  Backup catcher Austin Romine holds better long-term value than McCann so I think the Yankees should throw in cash to entice the Atlanta Braves to take their former All-Star catcher.

The next call up should be outfielder Aaron Judge, although I really want to see what first baseman Tyler Austin can do in September.

Austin_Tyler_05-848x576

Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRider’s Tyler Austin before a game against the Charlotte Knights at PNC Field in Moosic, Pa. on Tuesday, June 7, 2016. Photo by Martin Griff

Credit:  Martin Griff

The DL is going to miss Mark Teixeira…

Today, Mark Teixeira announced he is retiring at the end of the year.  This was the right move.  With his injury history in recent years, no team was going to pay him to be their starting first baseman next year.  There was no real chance that the Yankees would re-sign him.  It is time.  Teixeira now gets the opportunity to walk away as a Yankee.

usa-today-8727124.0

Credit:  Brad Rempel, USA Today Sports

I did not realize that Teixeira had hit nearly half of his career home runs as a Yankee.  It’s been eight years and is the longest time Tex has spent with any team including his original team, the Texas Rangers.

I saw a stat today that said the Yankees have only had four first basemen since 1983.  Don Mattingly, Tino Martinez, Jason Giambi, and Teixeira.  Unfortunately, that’s probably the order in which I liked them the best too.  Does this mean I will like the next first baseman even less?  Possibly, but the next first baseman should be the first homegrown Yankee since Mattingly.  The aforementioned Tyler Austin and the injured Greg Bird will enter spring training next year as the favorites for the position, along with Rob Refsnyder.  I like Bird, but I am very intrigued by Austin.  He responded very well to the position change to first this year and re-established himself as one of the top prospects in the organization.

I will be happy with either Austin or Bird, but I do hope that one of them takes the position by stranglehold and that it’s not just a process of elimination.  No offense to Refsnyder but he just doesn’t have the power to intrigue me as the regular first baseman.

Tex has had a great career.  I don’t know if it will lead to the Hall of Fame but he’s certainly put up numbers to be proud of.  He is one of the primary reasons the Yankees won the 2009 World Series.  Although I never fully embraced Teixeira, he was an excellent defensive first baseman and when healthy, one of the best power hitters in the game.  Sadly, the latter was an infrequent occurrence.

Still, I wish Tex nothing but the best as he moves on to his second career.

I hope it’s not Miller Time…

I am writing this post as the Yankees play the Cleveland Indians.  This is a very tough series to watch knowing that Cleveland has the premier closer on their roster.  Hopefully he doesn’t factor into tonight’s game.  But when he does appear, I hope he receives a standing ovation from the Yankee Stadium crowd.

AndrewMiller_1101001_640x360

Credit:  Jason Miller, Getty Images

Is it 2017 yet?…

—Scott

We’ve got a deal for you…

The fire sale has begun…

87a75036c55ccbabb07aca20e71aebf5_large

Apparently, Yankee Ownership has reached the same conclusion as the rest of us.  The 2016 Yankees aren’t going anywhere and can make other plans for October.

With the Aroldis Chapman trade, the Yankees were still committed to the 2016 season as Chapman was a surplus at the back end of the rotation.  But with today’s trade of Andrew Miller to the Cleveland Indians, the team has raised the white flag.  Dellin Betances has moved very quickly from the 7th inning reliever to Closer.  Perhaps it was always his job.  There was a certain air of destiny as a homegrown talent from the Bronx.  Miller and Chapman proved themselves elsewhere before they came to New York, but Dellin has been a Yankee from the start.

Now we need new setup guys…

I was reading that Yankees reliever Bryan Mitchell is nearly healthy again and will be on a rehab assignment as soon as next week.  At the beginning of the year, he was expected to the new Adam Warren.  But now when he comes back, he’ll have to fight Adam Warren to be the new Adam Warren given the latter’s return to New York in the Chapman trade.

The days of a six inning lead and game over are history.  It was fun while it lasted.  How great it would have/could have been if the Yankees had shown any offensive ability during the course of the season.  But for the Bronx Bumblers, having the greatest bullpen ever didn’t mean anything.

Despite the lack of a quality farm system just a few years ago, the Yankees have clearly brought an infusion of high level talent that is re-shaping the Yankees top prospects list.  C Gary Sanchez was the top prospect for years until he started to slide down a couple of notches.  Most recently, SS Jorge Mateo held the spot.  With the Chapman trade, SS Gleyber Torres became the Yankees’ top prospect and Mateo became a second baseman on the A level Tampa Yankees.  Now, with OF Clint Frazier on board in the Miller trade, there’s a good chance that he pushes Torres down the list.  Getting the top prospect from two other organizations is quite a haul.

12938249-standard

Credit:  The Plain Dealer

The Yankees also acquired the Indians’ #5 prospect in LHP Justus Sheffield.  He is the second rated pitcher for Cleveland behind P Brady Aiken.

I can’t help but wonder if the infusion of quality young talent might be a precursor for a trade to get someone like P Chris Sale.  I doubt it, but the Yankees will certainly have more options in 2017 as they look to rebuild the team.

There’s no doubt that I would just bite the bullet on the Alex Rodriguez contract and release him.    At this point, A-Rod has no defined role and is unable to contribute commensurate with the contract.  If Greg Bird was healthy, I’d say the same for Mark Teixeira but he’s not so the Yanks will have to stay with Tex for now.

With young outfielders like Aaron Judge and Clint Frazier soon ready to knock on the door at the major league level, I have to wonder how much longer Brett Gardner will be a Yankee.  If the team truly makes a run at Bryce Harper in a couple of years, they’ll have to move out some outfielders.

It’s very easy to get excited about Frazier.  Per MLB.com’s 2016 Prospect Watch:

Frazier’s bat speed and raw power are among the best in the Minor Leagues and suggest the ceiling of an All-Star. Though he struggled to harness his aggressive approach and recognize spin early in his career, Frazier has developed into a more complete hitter as he’s climbed the Minor League ladder, with strikeout and walk rates that continue to trend in a positive direction.

As a centerfielder, his job will be to make Jacoby Ellsbury expendable.

Now that Chapman and Miller are gone, the Yankees should focus on moving Carlos Beltran and Brian McCann.  Beltran has been a great Yankee this season but the contract’s soon up and there’s no chance the Yankees will re-sign him at age 40.  So, it’s better to get some value before he walks away since the team is not a contender this year.  With McCann, the Yankees have to create opportunity for Gary Sanchez and Austin Romine has proven he belongs as a major league backup.  With McCann on the roster, the Yankees would have to move or cut Romine to create the room for Sanchez.  I’d rather see McCann go.

I am excited to see the wealth of young talent enter the organization, but admittedly, it is very hard to see guys like Andrew Miller leave.  He was such a great team guy who never put his own self interests first.  Whatever the role, he could be counted on to deliver.  Tito Francona is going to be very pleased with his bullpen now.  Miller was my favorite Yankee after the retirement of Mariano Rivera.  I guess I need to find a new favorite now…

yankees-orioles-baseball

Credit:  Patrick Semansky, AP

As hard as it is to see Chapman and now Miller in other uniforms, I know that this is for the good of the organization.  I don’t see any other players on the roster that are capable of bringing in the other organization’s top prospect.  Well, maybe Dellin Betances, but he’s not going anywhere.

These are the days that will define GM Brian Cashman’s legacy.

—Scott

Can I have the cake and eat it too?…

What if the Yankees had traded Mariano Rivera in a deadline deal?…

It’s tough.  I’ve been preaching the Yankees need to sell and I still believe it.  Yet, it was very hard to watch Aroldis Chapman and his 105 mph fastball move to Chicago.  I know, it was the right thing to do.  The Yankees got a player (SS Gleyber Torres) that knocked #1 prospect SS Jorge Mateo off his perch.  They also got promising talent with two other minor leaguers, and the bonus included former Yankee Adam Warren, the perfect spot starter/long reliever.  He should slot nicely into the 7th inning role departed by Dellin Betances when he was promoted to the 8th inning with the trade.

29dellin-blog480

Credit:  Barton Silverman/New York Times

Andrew Miller is my favorite Yankee.  Going back, my favorite Yankees have been long-term affairs.  I became a Yankees fan in 1974 when P Jim “Catfish” Hunter signed with the Yankees as a free agent.  But it didn’t take long for me to jump to C Thurman Munson as my favorite.  There was a short stint with P Rich “Goose” Gossage, but then 1B Don Mattingly became my favorite.  When Mattingly retired, Mariano Rivera, then an 8th inning set up reliever for closer John Wetteland became my favorite Yankee.  So, from 1983 to 2013, there were two players that were my favorite.  When Andrew Miller joined the Yankees, he became my favorite due to his unselfish, total team approach.  He’s been great at whatever role he’s held with the Yankees and has never complained.  He is now the closer again with Chapman joining the Cubbies.  Yet, with several days to the trade deadline, Miller could still soon be an ex-Yankee.

andrew-miller

Credit:  Elsa/Getty Images

There was a report today that the Washington Nationals might be willing to part with pitcher Lucas Giolito for Miller.  A subsequent report indicated the Yankees would not take Giolito for Miller.  Realistically and considering he is my favorite Yankee, that’s a trade that I would do with no questions asked.  I think Giolito has a very promising future.  There are no guarantees for anyone unless your name is Mike Trout or Bryce Harper.  Pitchers are very fickle.  The Los Angeles Dodgers have the best pitcher in baseball with Clayton Kershaw yet he is on the DL and there’s no word when he’ll be returning.  The Yankees need a New York Mets-like starting rotation and I feel that Giolito could be a cornerstone.  I would hate to lose Miller, and I would be very sad to see him go even if Giolito is the compensation.  Yet, I feel the Yankees would be better off long-term with a potential ace in the rotation and Dellin Betances as the closer.

The Yankees have played better of late but realistically this is not a World Series team.  The Yankees really need to make decisions now to influence the 2017 roster.  That means they need to move guys like Ivan Nova and Carlos Beltran.  Get prospects rather than see the players depart at the end of the year.  I am prepared to cut bait with Mark Teixeira, Alex Rodriguez and CC Sabathia.  I’d try to move C Brian McCann and 3B Chase Headley.  I’d also check to see if there was any value for LF Brett Gardner.  I wouldn’t trade P Masahiro Tanaka but I’d seriously have to consider moving Michael Pineda and/or Nathan Eovaldi in the right deal.

The influx of additional young talent could allow the Yankees to make a deal for a guy like P Chris Sale or another impact player.

Owner Hal Steinbrenner and President Randy Levine still believe in the 2016 Yankees but they are definitely in the minority.  The Yankees, behind GM Brian Cashman, need to be forward-thinking.  The next couple of days will be crucial to the future of the franchise.

As painful as it is, please sell…

Unknown

—Scott

Which direction is the wind blowing?…

To sell or not to sell…

Buy-Hold-Sell

Should the Yankees be buyers or sellers?  That seems to be the burning question circulating the Yankee fan base.  It’s clear that the 2016 Yankees are not going anywhere.  Even if they did somehow snag the second Wild Card spot, what would they do with it?  Nothing.  They do not match up well with the better teams in the AL and if the big hitters on the team can’t hit in July, they sure won’t be hitting in October when the best pitchers are facing them.

Sell.

The answer is plain and simple.  I think the Yankees could get more for Aroldis Chapman than if they take the compensatory pick when he walks at the end of the year.  Carlos Beltran has proven to be a much better Yankee than expected but his time in the Bronx is over.  Let Nathan Eovaldi figuure out how to control those 100 mph pitches in PIttsburgh.  I’d move Brian McCann to someplace like Texas or another team in need of a quality catcher.  I’d cut Alex Rodriguez outright, and take the rest of the contract as the cost of doing business.

toon526

Granted, Aaron Judge is currently on the minor league DL but the Yankees need to find ways to get the younger talent exposed to the major leagues this year.  I’d like to see Jake Cave have the opportunity he had in spring training when he was trying to make the Cincinnati Reds as a Rule 5 draftee.  It didn’t work them but I think he has continued to grow and might be the fourth outfielder that Aaron Hicks is not.  Tyler Austin is another possibility.

I realize that pitcher Drew Pomeranz is having a great year, and was once a fifth selection overall in the draft, but he is still a journeyman pitcher.  For the success he’s enjoyed this year, the San Diego Padres were able to pry the fourth best prospect from the Boston Red Sox in pitcher Anderson Espinoza.  Watching the Red Sox beat the Yankees yesterday, their starter was Eduardo Rodriguez.  Rodriguez was the product of a trading deadline deal a couple of years ago when Boston was seller (sending current Yankee Andrew Miller to Baltimore).  Being sellers paid dividends for the Red Sox.

Retooling this team is not going to work.  The Yankees need to make some extreme choices, and then stand behind those moves.  There’s help on the way in the lower levels of the minor league system, with a few options currently at the AAA level.  But those players need to be supplemented by other high level prospects.

It’s been frustrating to watch the Yankees fight to .500 at the All-Star Break, only to lose the first two games of a three game set with the Red Sox.  But this is the 2016 Yankees.  It’s not going to get any better.

I personally would can Joe Girardi as manager, but that’s not a move that necessarily needs to be made to improve the team over the long haul.  Maybe it is time to make a change at the GM level.  Bring an outside perspective into the organization.  I would love for the team to find a way to pry Alex Anthopoulos away from the Los Angeles Dodgers.

The best move would be for the Steinbrenner family to sell the team but that’s not going to happen.  So, sell the older players with value, and move on.  2016 is lost.  Prepare this team for 2017 and beyond.  We need to recapture New York from the Mets and give the fans reason for hope…

So long, Aroldis.  It’s been fun…

19941196-mmmain

Credit:  Kim Klement, USA Today Sports

—Scott

Seriously, a BJ Upton walk-off homer?…

Glass is half empty…

When the Yankees split the recent series with the Texas Rangers by taking back-to-back walk-off wins, there was talk if those games were the momentum changers that the Yankees needed to propel them upward in the standings.  Off to San Diego to play the lowly Padres, and the Yankees have only continued their disappointing and at times frustrating play.

funny-cats-compilation-most-see-1

When you can say that Ivan Nova held the opponent to one run with seven strikeouts, it should be a sign of optimism.  But in the standings, it was just another loss as the Padres’ Drew Pomeranz threw a superior game.  Is Pomeranz really that good or is it just the miserable Yankee bats?  Probably somewhere in between.

Every fan has known for several years that the Yankees need another top starter to go with Masahiro Tanaka.  There was hope and optimism that Michael Pineda and/or Luis Severino would step up but it hasn’t happened and there was always the potential for this to be the case.  Neither is a surefire option.  I still think the Yankees should have gone after Max Scherzer a couple of seasons ago, but it wasn’t meant to be.

635574523060804005-USP-MLB-Washington-Nationals-Press-Conference

Credit:  Geoff Burke, USA Today Sports

Regardless of what happens in the coming days, I think it is time to move pending free agent Carlos Beltran.  Yes, he’s been the best offensive force on the team, but face it, the Yankees aren’t going to win the World Series this year.  Beltran will walk at the end of the year as the Yankees have no desire to re-sign the player.  They may as well sell at this point to get something of value in return.  The day for Aaron Judge’s arrival is drawing closer.  Even if Judge isn’t ready, there are guys like Jake Cave who deserve an opportunity.  The Yankees should commit to youth for the good of the organization going forward.

yankees-spring-training

Credit:  Corey Sipkin, New York Daily News

I would also sell high on CC Sabathia.  The guy was untradeable in the not so distant past.  Now, the Yankees could actually get something in return even if they have to pay some of the salary.  A great Yankee but it’s time to move on.  I’d rather begin to develop guys like Chad Green and Luis Cessa as long time parts for the starting rotation.

I’d sign Cuban free agent third baseman Yulieski Gourriel and unload Chase Headley.

84297044kd006-world-basebal

Credit:  Kevork Djansezian, Getty Images

There’s no doubt I’d walk away from Alex Rodriguez, and take the remaining dollars as a loss on the contract as the cost of doing business.  I would also move on from Mark Teixeira despite no readily apparent back up in place.  These guys have been huge drains on the team’s offense, and perhaps they’d flourish elsewhere with the change of scenery but I don’t see either player powering the team to its 28th World Championship.

If Brett Gardner got caught in one of the moves to unload one or more of the above players, then so be it.

The Yankees need to develop a stronger base foundation so that they can enhance the team in the off-season through other trades or possible free agent signings.  I know that the free agent market doesn’t appear to be very attractive this year, but the Yankees need to do something to remove the “past-their-prime” players.

As for youth, I was hoping for more from Aaron Hicks.  I really thought that he might flourish in the Bronx and give the Yankees stronger reason to move Brett Gardner.  But he hasn’t hit either.  Maybe the Yankees should consider adding former Twins outfielder Torii Hunter as a roving instructor.  Hicks blossomed last year under his tutelage.  I still think that Hicks can succeed, but it is rapidly becoming apparent it won’t be this year.

It was frustrating in the off-season to watch the Yankees be so inactive in improving the roster.  We’re now seeing the uneven play of the team as a result.  I think the fans knew that was the more likely outcome than management did.  It doesn’t mean the fans are more educated, but clearly this was a roster full of holes that needed everything to go right.

francisofassisi121023

Today, Chad Green is the starting pitcher as the Yankees try to salvage at least one game from the San Diego Padres and avoid a sweep.  Hopefully it is the sign of the future, and the first step toward “roster improvement”.

Yankees, just win…

—Scott

.500 R Us…

Win some, lose some…

The Yankees continue to lose but win just enough to make you think that IF everything could fall into place, they might have a shot for a wild card berth.  This is actually frustrating because the Yankees do not have the horses to succeed in October outside of a legendary back end of the bullpen.

al-baseball

Credit:  Brad Penner, USA Today Sports

There have been a few surprises like the improved pitching of CC Sabathia, but the inconsistency of the starting rotation as a whole and the lack of a true superstar in the heart of the order can only mean the Yankees will be picking in the mid-first round again next June in the amateur draft.

I’ve been pleased with the recent play of Didi Gregorius but he’s still just a place card until top prospect Jorge Mateo is ready for the big leagues.  In looking at the Yankees infield, it’s hard to imagine anyone other than Starlin Castro still starting at his position three years from now.  Mark Teixeira will be a memory from days past, Brian McCann will probably be the team’s primary DH, and Chase Headley will be making his second go-around in San Diego or some other obscure baseball community.

I have mixed feelings about a July sell-off.  The Yankees can certainly get value for guys like Aroldis Chapman and/or Andrew Miller but a stellar bullpen is hard to find these days and is a must to succeed in the play-offs.  If the Yankees are indeed out of it, I wouldn’t mind seeing Carlos Beltran moved for prospects or almost anyone else on the team except for Dellin Betances, Miller and Chapman.  I guess if the Yankees are offered a player like the Cubs’ Kyle Schwarber, then you do have to consider moving even Run BMC but I hope it doesn’t come to that.  Since Mariano Rivera retired, Andrew Miller has been my favorite Yankee.  Before Rivera was my favorite, it was Don Mattingly.  I am used to players with very long tenures in New York.  The difference with Miller is that he was not home-grown.  He made his name before coming to New York.

STON4064.JPG

(070711 Boston, MA) Boston Red Sox starting pitcher Andrew Miller pitches in the first inning of a MLB game against the Baltimore Orioles at Fenway Park Thursday, July 7, 2011. Staff Photo by Matt Stone

If the Yankees decide they can re-sign Chapman, then maybe moving Miller is the right thing.  But if Chapman isn’t traded and is allowed to walk at the end of the year, the Yankees need Miller as their closer.  I prefer to see Betances stay in a setup role.  I hope he doesn’t become the closer by default.

Trading Chapman or Miller is easy, GM Brian Cashman would really make a name for himself (above and beyond his current reputation) if he was able to unload some dead wood.  Yes, I am talking about Alex Rodriguez and Mark Teixeira but there’s obviously others.

Life in the AL East…

I am surprised that the Baltimore Orioles are starting to run away with the division.  Honestly, I thought it would be a slugfest between the Toronto Blue Jays and the Boston Red Sox.  After a strong start, Boston has been very sluggish of late as they’ve fallen off the pace with the O’s.  David Price has looked nothing like the ace pitcher he is paid to be.  This really shows what a crap shoot free agent signings can be, particularly with pitchers.  Maybe Hal Steinbrenner is on to something by not signing any top shelf free agents in the recent past.

11b1a12

Speaking of Boston, I think they’d be wise to fire manager John Farrell and replace him with last year’s interim manager Torey Lovullo.  Lovullo did a great job last year getting the most out of his players after he replaced the sidelined Farrell.  The 2016 Red Sox seem to be missing something, and it might be having Lovullo as its manager.  But then again, if Farrell causes the Red Sox to miss the play-offs, all is good and they should keep him as manager…

With the Yankees right now, it feels like we’re sitting around waiting for Bryce Harper’s free agent year…

Washington Nationals Photo Day

VIERA, FL – FEBRUARY 23: Bryce Harper #34 of the Washington Nationals poses for a portrait during photo day at Space Coast Stadium on February 23, 2014 in Viera, Florida. (Photo by Rob Carr/Getty Images)

Credit:  Rob Carr, Getty Images

Half the year is gone…where did it go?  Welcome to July and the baseball trading deadline…

—Scott

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.